Reply to comment

Re: Electoral power, really?

I could certainly be wrong about how influential they are in Swedish politics: the Piratpartiet wasn't my only informant on that question, but still I'm probably talking to a biased group of people.

But what you wrote...

"They have no political agenda what so ever exept for handing out CDs with illegal copies movies and music. I actually met them once. For me it was obvious that their 'opinion', politics or what ever you want to call it is a attempt for moralizing their activities when it's in fact kids (adults according to to law) wanting their candy for free."

...is simply wrong, and that I can be certain of.

I've talked to Rick at length and in great detail about the Piratpartiet's platform; I've seen him give speeches and answer audience questions about it; I've read their campaign literature. They have a real agenda, their concerns (especially about civil liberties) are my concerns too, and it really has nothing to do with wanting to pay less for music.

In fact, the Piratpartiet's platform is very similar to many positions QuestionCopyright.org advocates. If you don't think this web site is about "kids wanting their candy for free" — and it's hard to imagine how you could — then there's no reason not to take the Piratpartiet at their word.

They really do mean what they say. You may disagree with them, but you don't do the debate any favors by attacking a caricature of their actual positions.

Reply

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
(This is to prove that you are a human, not a spam-bot. Note that you will need both Javascript and cookies enabled for this.)